Homemade donuts display at Fehr's Heritage Bakery with chalkboard labels showing Choc Peanut, Choc Glaze, Coconut, Vanilla Glaze, Cinn Sugar, and Plain varieties

Fehr's Heritage Bakery

Come and taste the difference of homemade

970 Heritage Rd, Kingsville, ON (519) 733-0303
Our Products Get Directions
Exterior of Fehr's Heritage Bakery, a white building with a hand-painted sign, white picket fence, and steps leading to the entrance

Our Heritage

Everything made from scratch, the way it should be

Tucked away on Heritage Road in Kingsville, Fehr's Heritage Bakery is a Mennonite family bakery where every pie, tart, and loaf is made by hand with local ingredients. All pie fillings are prepared in-house with local berries and fruit, and each pie is packed with pounds of filling.

Visitors call it a hidden gem — the kind of place you discover once and never stop returning to.

What We Bake

Baked fresh, sold fast

A fresh blueberry pie with golden flaky crust and fruit bubbling through the top at Fehr's Heritage Bakery
01

Homemade Pies

Apple, blueberry, strawberry rhubarb, cherry, pecan, lemon meringue, and more. Local fruit, flaky dough, pounds of filling in every pie.

Rows of fresh butter tarts with golden pastry and rich fillings including raisin and plain varieties
02

Butter Tarts

Raisin, pecan, coconut, walnut, cherry, lemon, and butter. Soft, delicate dough. Reviewers call them the best in Ontario.

A display case of homemade donuts at Fehr's Heritage Bakery with varieties including chocolate glaze, coconut, vanilla glaze, cinnamon sugar, and plain
03

Homemade Donuts

Chocolate peanut, chocolate glaze, coconut, vanilla glaze, cinnamon sugar, and plain. Fresh daily and generously sized.

Loaves of fresh homemade whole wheat bread in bags on the bakery shelf
04

Fresh Breads

Whole wheat, sourdough, Italian seasoning, garlic and cheese, jalapeno bacon, apple cinnamon raisin, and more. Baked daily.

See All Products

What People Say

Worth the trip

4.7 stars from 98 reviews

"Every single thing they have is delicious. This is food made the right way! I've never once been disappointed in anything they have. Heritage Bakery has by far the best banana cream pie I've ever had! Such a gem."

Nora Bock

"Tucked away on its own, but a must stop. Everything unique and always fresh that day. Great selection of baked goods and will always find something you can't get elsewhere."

Brad Daneliuk

"BEST PIES I have had!!! Ordered pies for the first time for the holidays. Every pie was enjoyed by many. Will definitely be visiting the bakery again and again."

Denise Rickard

Come visit us

We are on Heritage Road in Kingsville. Open Tuesday through Saturday. Call ahead to reserve your favorites.

(519) 733-0303 Get Directions